Eternal Flame Falls near Buffalo in western New York is one of just nine natural eternal flames in the world. It sits behind a cascading waterfall in a beautiful fusion of fire and water, and the hiking trail leading to the flame is open every day. Parking was completely free and the trail itself was more enjoyable than we expected, so be sure to put this hike on your to-do list.
Kristen is from the Finger Lakes and went to UB, and we’re Bills fans so you’re getting a locals take here! In this guide we explain you everything you need to know about hiking to Eternal Flame Falls.
We hiked the Eternal Flame Falls Trail together with Kristen’s mom before going to watch a Bills game on a Sunday afternoon in fall. The photos in this guide are from our October 2022 visit when the leaves had just fallen. Read more about us.
Parts of the trail were actually pretty slippery so take extra care if you visit at the same time we did. Okay, let’s begin!
Note: This article may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase using one of these affiliate links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you!
What Is Eternal Flame Falls?
- Waterfall Height: 30 ft (9m)
- Waterfall Crest: Varies
- Waterway: Shale Creek
- Location: Erie County
- Nearest Major City: Orchard park (4.5 miles)
Eternal Flame Falls is a unique waterfall located in western New York state. It features a mini grotto with a natural flame occurring near a 30 ft waterfall cascade. Inside the small alcove, there is a natural gas spring showcasing a flickering blaze ranging from about 4 to 8 inches in height.
The water flow from Shale Creek pours over the small flame creating a magnificence spectacle. We love this waterfall because you can visit any time of year and it’s always breathtaking.
There are various legends as to the origin of the flame. Some say it was lit thousands of years ago by Indigenous groups who called this area home. Another popular story involves defiant elves living in the nearby woodlands who continuously light the flame.
But the real mystery lies with the natural gasses that are pushed through the cracks of the surrounding bedrock. In 2013, a study from Indiana University, discovered Eternal Flame Falls in New York contains the highest concentrations of ethane and propane of any known natural gas seep.
The small grotto acts as a shelter to protect the gas seepage so the flame can remain lit for long periods of time. Research has concluded the flame originates from Rhinestreet Shale formed during the Upper Devonian period about 400 meters deep.
The natural gas eventually reaches the surface of the ground through faults and passages caused by tectonic activity. While there are other tiny fissures nearby, they are not nearly as impressive compared to the primary flame near the waterfall.
Directions To The Park
Eternal Flame Falls is nestled on the southern end of Chestnut Ridge Park along Shale Creek about 20 miles south of Buffalo, New York. The park includes 1,200 acres of the beautiful rolling hills in Erie County wedged between Eighteenmile Creek and the western branch of Cazenovia Creek. The Shale Creek Preserve is located within the remote southern region of the park and it’s filled with wooded ravines.
- Address: Eternal Flame Hiking Trail, Orchard Park, NY 14127
- Location: Google Maps
From Buffalo, follow I-190 S, then I-90 W and finally US-219 S to New Armour Rd in Orchard Park. Take the exit toward Chestnut Ridge Park from US-219 and follow signs to the park. The gravel parking lot will be on your left.
Let’s take a quick look at driving distances and times from nearby major cities as well as the closest airports for you to consider if visiting from further afield.
Eternal Flame Falls distance from nearby major cities:
- Binghamton, NY – 190 miles (3h 30m)
- Syracuse, NY – 160 miles (2h 30m)
- Rochester, NY – 85 miles (1h 30m)
- Albany, NY – 300 miles (4h 30m)
- NYC – 365 miles (6h 15m)
- Erie, PA – 90 miles (1h 30m)
Entry Fee And Parking
You don’t have to pay an entrance fee and you don’t need a reservation to enter Chestnut Ridge Park. And unlike most New York parks, you don’t have to pay a day-use vehicle parking fee. The park is completely free to enter from 7:00am to dusk in winter and until 9:00pm in summer.
We like Eternal Flame Falls because parking is relatively easy compared to other famous hikes in the United States. When you first arrive, you’ll pull into a huge gravel parking lot. The trailhead is found in the southwest corner of the lot.
While this large parking lot rarely fills to full capacity, the trail and area around the eternal flame itself is quite restricted. So if the parking lot is packed, just be aware the trail will be very busy and there will be limited space to spread out from others.
Since Chestnut Ridge is open year round, it’s a popular spot for winter activities due to its close proximity to Buffalo. However, this hike can be extremely dangerous in the winter months due to heavy snow and thick ice.
Eternal Flame Falls sits within a large ravine and it can be difficult to see the trail when the snow is deep. Use a hiking app in winter to help you find the correct path.
Eternal Flame Falls Trail Walkthrough
One of the most popular hikes within Chestnut Ridge Park is Eternal Flame Falls. It’s a short moderately challenging route due to the climb down into the ravine. Here is the official trail map from the Erie County Park System.
- Distance: 1.12 miles roundtrip
- Difficulty: Moderate
We recommend wearing proper hiking shoes or boots, and in the winter you may want to consider wearing microspikes. According to All Trails, the hike about 30 minutes to complete and you can check recent comments to see what hikers have said about the current conditions.
Okay, let’s hike to Eternal Flame Falls!
1. Chestnut Ridge Parking Lot
As you make your way to the official trailhead, you’ll notice a large sign indicating the trail for Eternal Flame Falls. Take a moment to read the sign for any important information you may need to know about the area including trail hazards or weather concerns.
As you head west, you’ll also notice the trail is marked with small flame markers nailed to trees. These markers will show you how far you have hiked. Shortly you’ll enter a large grove of Hemlock trees and you’ll remain in the shade for the rest of the hike.
2. Hemlock Trees
As you follow the trail, it becomes extremely peaceful as you walk through the trees. During our hike, we didn’t see another person until we reached the creek and it was eerily quiet for this first section.
Something important to note about this area is you’ll pass by the large ravine which is home to the waterfall housing the eternal flame. It might be tempting to take this shortcut, but DO NOT attempt to climb down the ravine because people have died trying to reach the flame this way.
The walls are steeper than they look from the top and it’s extremely dangerous. Please leave no trace and follow the path because it was designed to help you reach the flame safely as well as minimize our impact on the environment.
3. Descent To Shale Creek
The trail will begin to loop back around as you begin a descent to the Shale Creek. Watch out for thick roots and rocks embedded in the trail. There are a few wooden steps which have been added to help you climb down the ravine.
4. Rotten Egg Smell
Once you reach Shale Creek, you might notice a faint smell of rotten eggs. This is the natural gas found in the area. The smell will get stronger the closer you get to the flame.
5. Creek Obstacles
The hike will continue through Shale Creek. When we visited in October, the water level was extremely low and we could easily navigate this section of the trail. If you visit in spring when the snowpack is melting, you may have to walk through water to reach Eternal Flame Falls.
This section can be a bit difficult to navigate because there any many obstacles including large branches and pools of water. Take your time and make sure you watch your footing.
6. Flame View
In our opinion, the best part of this hike is when you get that first glimpse of the cascading waterfall with the shimmering red light in person. It almost looks like a mirage, but it looks just like the photos you’ve seen online which isn’t always the case.
Sometimes flooding, pressure changes and snow may extinguish the flame, but it can be easily re-lit with a lighter. The trail ends at the waterfall so take a break and enjoy the views. Once you’ve taken your photos, begin making your way back up the creek and follow the same trail back to the parking lot. Please do not try to climb the ravine to get out.
Facilities And More Trails
There is only one outhouse located on the side of the parking lot at Eternal Flame Falls. If you need additional facilities during your visit, head to the main section of Chestnut Ridge Park or nearby Orchard Park.
Dogs are allowed on the trail, but must always be kept on a leash. However, the trail can be very slippery in sections so always keep a close eye on your pet. We saw a few dogs during our hike and they sure loved dodging the large branches in Shale Creek.
Opened in 1926, Chestnut Ridge Park is one of the original Erie County Parks. After hiking to Eternal Flame Falls, use this map here to find more trails.
Here are additional hikes and distances are one way:
- Boy Scout Trail – 2.3 miles
- Orienteering Trail – 2.6 miles
- Reservoir Trail – 0.65 miles
- Seufert Trail – 0.23 miles
- Snowmobile Trail – 0.34 miles
- Ward Hill Trail – 0.90 miles
- Ward Hill Walkway – 1.15 miles
Hiking Tip: In the winter season, there are two cross country skiing trails including both an inner and outer loop.
Best Time To Visit
Eternal Flame Falls will be extremely busy on weekends between May and October, particularly during the holidays. We recommend avoiding this peak season unless it’s the only time you can visit.
Our favorite time to hike to Eternal Flame Falls is the last week of September or first week of October. This time of year showcases vibrant fall foliage throughout the ravine and the water level is low in the creek so you can easily visit without getting too wet.
If you want to see the waterfall at it fullest, visit in early spring when the snow is melting. However, it may be difficult to walk through Shale Creek and sometimes the flame is hidden behind heavy water flow. We recommend you wear water proof boots if you want to visit at this time of year.
Early morning is the best time of day no matter the season because you’ll beat the crowds. We started our hike around 10:00 am on a Sunday in October and only saw a few others on the trail.
Where To Eat And Stay
We visited the waterfall before a Buffalo Bills game at Highmark Stadium at Orchard Park and stopped at the Anchor Bar for dinner. You could also combine this hike with a visit to Niagara Falls because it’s only about 40 miles to the north. While you’ll find several chain restaurants nearby, we always recommend you support the local options to help the community.
Here are some top rated hotel and restaurant recommendations for your trip:
Best hotel options:
- Hampton Inn (East Aurora) – 11 miles to the falls
- Hampton Inn (Hamburg) – 8 miles to the falls
- Holiday Inn Express (Hamburg) – 8 miles to the falls
- Staybridge Suites (West Seneca) – 11 miles to the falls
- The Fields of Eden Inn – 11 miles to the falls
Popular restaurants nearby:
- Bella Pizza Boston – Oversized slices, Italian staples + family combo meals
- Cozy Thai Restaurant – Family-owned Thai cafe with traditional meals
- JP Fitzgeralds – Busy Irish sports pub with 20+ TVs + popcorn machine
- The Grange Community Kitchen – Seasonal salads, pizza + steak
- Ted’s Hot Dogs – Long-running chain serving hot dogs + fast-food
Travel Tip: If this is your first time in Buffalo, we recommend you try the Anchor Bar, home of the original buffalo style chicken wing and one of Kristen’s favorite restaurants!
The Morgan Conclusion
Eternal Flame Falls is moderately challenging 1.2 mile out and back hike featuring a deep ravine and the Shale Creek. It’s a hidden gem in western New York that packs a big punch.
But is Eternal Flame Falls worth visiting?
Yes, we think Eternal Flame Falls is worth it because it’s a short hike that can be enjoyed by the entire family. In addition to the trail, there are many other outdoor activities you can enjoy including picnicking, disc golf, playgrounds, sledding, snowmobiling and cross country skiing in Chestnut Ridge Park. If you’re looking for a unique hike that you’ll always remember, this is it!
Our Eternal Flame Falls Photos
We loved visiting in October and took many photos. Here are a few more of our favorites so you know exactly what to expect during your trip:
More From The Finger Lakes
- Amazing things to do in the NY Finger Lakes
- Guide to Watkins Glen Gorge Trail to Rainbow Falls hike
- Things to do in the Village of Watkins Glen
- Best places to visit in Ithaca, New York
- Tips for visiting the Corning Museum of Glass
- How to visit Letchworth State Park in NY
- Hiking the Bluffs Trail at Chimney Bluffs State Park
- Guide to visiting Buttermilk Falls State Park
- How to visit Grimes Glen Park near Naples
- Hiking Robert H. Treman Gorge to Lucifer Falls
- Hike to New York’s Taughannock Falls
- Guide to visiting Green Lakes State Park
- Where to find the best waterfalls in the Finger Lakes
Want more New York content? Head over to our New York Travel Guides to explore the Finger Lakes, Adirondacks and the best of NYC.
We hope our guide to hiking to Eternal Flame Falls helps with planning your visit to upstate New York!
Please let us know if you have any questions in the comments below.
Happy Hiking,
Mark and Kristen
Enjoy this guide? Pin it for later!
All Rights Reserved © Where Are Those Morgans, LLC. Republishing this article and/or any of its contents (text, photography, maps, graphics, etc.) in whole or in part is strictly prohibited.
Mark and Kristen spent 6 years traveling the world, visiting over 40 countries across 4 continents and more than 30 US states. They created Where Are Those Morgans in 2018 to help others plan the best possible vacations by writing authentic travel and hiking guides based on their real experiences.
Since the arrival of baby Maya in late 2024, Mark and Kristen’s extensive travels have slowed down but they still take plenty of trips. Where Are Those Morgans now helps millions of travelers each year to visit new places and hike new trails through information-packed blog posts and expert travel guidebooks. Read more about Mark and Kristen.